The work of the Community of Sant'Egidio is made thanks to volunteers and is financed by collections, contributes, donations, both public and private.

Help us to help

 You can make the difference for many

 

             


change language
you are in: home - ecumenis...dialogue - internat...or peace - sarajevo 2012 contacting usnewsletterlink

Support The Community

 

Sant'Egidio in Africa: a response of mercy and hope to meet the new challenges of globalisation

The East African Communities gathered in Uganda continue their work: "To promote the role of women in society, to accompany the young, protect the elderly, the weak and the poor"

Ivory Coast: the meeting with the street children of Abidjan that tell the dreams and difficulties of a generation

At the end of the conference of the Communities of Sant'Egidio of West Africa gathered in Ivory Coast with Andrea Riccardi

Solidarity on the road in Rome: university students of Sant'Egidio at the table with the poor and many friends

Supper in the streets with homeless, new Europeans and many families here is the face of solidarity in Rome

Summer of Sant'Egidio starts with the elderly in Europe, Africa and Asia

In Cameroon, Hungary, Pakistan: different places and weather conditions, but the love for the elderly is the same

 
printable version
September 11 2012 09:30 | National Theatre

50 years of Vatican II Has Dialogue a Future?



Mohammad Sammak


National Islamic-Christian Committee for Dialogue, Lebanon

To answer the question if Dialogue is valid 50 years after Vatican II, I have to underline three important issues;
1- Christian-Muslim relations before Vatican II,
2- The contribution of Vatican II to these relations,
3- Christian-Muslim relations after Vatican II.

(l) Before  Vatican II relations were very negative and even destructive. It was based on mutual ignorance and arrogance. Here are two examples using a lecture prepared by Michael Fitzgerald 25 April 2000 as a reference.1
a- A "monk of France", probably to be identified with Hugh of Cluny (1049-1119), wrote to the Muslim king of Saragossa, Muqtadir Billah, a letter inviting the ruler to embrace Christianity. In it he spoke about the deception of Islam, attributing it to the work of Satan. He stated: "Satan.. deceived the children of Ishmael in regard to the Prophet whose mission they acknowledged and thereby drew many souls to the punishment of Hell.2
b- An earlier writer, George Hamartolos, this time not in the West but in the Byzantine Empire, complied a history of mankind from its origins to the middle of the 91th Century. He dedicates one chapter, chapter 235, to Islam. He compares Islam unfavorably to Christianity, stating that it is a religion which spring from a false prophet. "These foggy­ minded and stupid men", he writes, "refuse openly to examine the truest faith, sacred and guaranteed by God, while these hardened wretches accept the forgery to which this swindler gave the appearance of true religion"3.

(2)Vatican II and Islam
Here it is worth noting that:
a- " The interest of the Council for Islam arose incidentally, out of the desire to produce a declaration about the Jews. There was no intention of providing a full discussion of Islamic beliefs and practices".4
b- The declaration of the council addressed Muslims as believers not Islam as a religion, and as a message from God. But it made it clear that the people which acknowledges God in truth and serves Him in holiness are related in some way to the People of God (lumen Gentium 16) -it is in fact in this context that we find the first mention of Muslims- primarily as individuals, secondarily as belonging to a different religion.
The statement in Lumen Gentium (n.16) says: "The plan of salvation also includes those who acknowledge the Creator, in the first place among whom are the Muslims : these profess to hold the faith of Abraham, and together with us they adore the one, merciful God, mankind's judge on the last day".
(3)Christian-Muslim relations after Vatican II.
It's  enough to compare between the two images of Islam before and after Vatican II in order to realize the importance and the profound change. It was a doctrinal change, that opened up bridges for mutual understanding and reconciliation. It was a change to the good and to the truth, since goodness, and truth are one.
From the Islamic perspective, to be a Muslim one has to believe in Christianity (and in Judaism) as a message from God. Doctrinally the Quran says about the Bible: "There is guidance and light in the Bible".. and "let the people of the Bible follow what God revealed to them in the Bible".
The Quran describes Christians as "believers" and says "they are most passionate because among them are priests and clergy", (taking into consideration that there is no priesthood in Islam). The Quran describes Mary as the chosen lady by God and the preferred by Him over ali women of the world.
The Quran describes Jesus as the word of God and a spirit from Him. Born from a virgin mother, and spoke to her the moment after birth. The Quran, though  describes him as a prophet, speaks about his miracles including healing the sick and raising the dead, by the will of God.
Before Vatican II, these doctrinal principles of Islam were not known, or were not well understood.
Understanding these doctrinal principles of Islam helped the Vatican II to reconsider the position of the church regarding Islam and Muslims.
So the term brothers were used for the first time and several times, by late Popes in their reference to Muslims (Paul VI in Uganda 1969, and Pope John Paul II in Morocco August 1985 ).
Muslims are not any more devils, fool and foggy minded. And Islam is not any more a Christian heresy. Islam as described by Vatican II, is now a religion worthy of respect.
Muslims expressed honest openness and constructive desires to build bridges of respect and cooperation with the Roly See based on this outcome. Today there are many Muslim-Vatican religious committees for dialogue; for example with Al-Azhar of Egypt; with Al-El-Beit of Jordan, and with the Islamic call of Libya.
There are also many Islamic initiatives: "The common word of love of God and love of neighbor", the "call to know each other", but the most important is the one taken by King Abdullah Ben Abdel Aziz, king of Saudi Arabia. This initiative which the Vatican was and still a strong supporter, is now an international Organization for interreligious and intercultural dialogue based in Vienna.
To my knowledge it is the first of its kind in the Muslim world, and maybe the first of its kind in modem history, because it includes representatives of Christianity, Judaism, Hinduism and Buddhism.
The importance of this organization is not simply for being the outcome of an Islamic initiative, but because it is an initiative of the Custodian of the Two Holy Masques himself and of what he represents. The king declared this initiative after two preliminary steps:
a-  Convening  an Islamic conference in Mekka for  religious scholars representing all Islamic confessions.
b- The symbolic visit of King to the Vatican and his cordial meeting with the Pope Benedict IVX
The Vatican participated drafting the constitution of this organization, and is an observer member in it.

So here we have two new principles:
First: Muslims as brothers to Christians, and Islam is a religion worthy of respect.
Second:  Islamic doctrinal belief that Christianity is a Heavenly message from God and Islamic initiative to translate these beliefs into actions. These two principles open up the avenues of dialogue on both directions. Results so far, are good, but expectations are higher. There are mistakes, but we learn from our mistakes more than we learn from our achievements.
Mistakes indicate that we should do better, and more. Mistakes do not and should not mean that the concept of bridges building is wrong.
The question now is, is it worthy? The answer is simple. Imagine if the Vatican II was not there, where Christians and Muslims will be now? will be  there diplomatic relations between the Holy See and Muslim states that represent about 1.5 billion Muslims?
A research published by Ipsos Mori, the global polling organization, and the
Tony Blair Faith Foundation, showed that:
a- 94% of respondents in three mainly Muslim countries (Saudi Arabia, Indonesia and Turkey) said that religion was important in their lives, where as 66% of self described Christians in 19 countries, said like wise. The percentage rises in the USA to 86%. The lowest is in France, 32%.
b- 61% of Muslims in the above mentioned three countries, said that they believe that their faith -Islam-  is the only true path to salvation and paradise; only 19% of Christians were similarly confident.

This research indicates that -with the heavy historical background- there is high tendency in the Islamic world to consider any conflict or tension with the West as religious, or has a religious background or at least has religious consequences. The research indicates too, that for the West, what creates tensions with Muslims is not Christian teachings or different ideas about the nature of God, but the lack of any religion in the public or private lives of many westerns.
This raises the issue of the relationship between religions and traditions.
Westerns are more attached to traditions than to religions. Muslims do not disengage traditions from religion. So the clash of traditions between westerns and Muslims becomes a clash of religions, which is not. The truth is that, religion is not tradition.
Sometimes there are even contradictions between the two. Dialogue is the best and the safest way to deal with this delicate and sensitive problem. It has been proved again and again, that the only substitute to dialogue is confrontation.  We tried it, and it lead to nowhere. With good will, and with good intentions, and with mutual respect to our both religious teachings, we should achieve more, and we can.




1 Michael Fitzgerald, “From Heresy to religion: Vatican II and Islam”. Lecture 25 April 2000
2 GAUDEUL, Encounters and Clashes, Vol.. II Texts, 396 p.
3 Ibid. Vol. III, p.19; cf. Vol. I pp67-68
4 Ibid.- Michael Fitzgerald

Message of His Holiness Benedict XVI
Benedict XVI

Programme in English
PDF

BROADCAST LIVE PROGRAMME

RELATED NEWS
July 7 2015
INDONESIA

In Jakarta Sant'Egidio makes a Ramadhan feast for more than 500 poor muslim children and families


The "buka puasa", traditional dinner for breaking the fast, becomes an occasion of getting together muslims and christians in the Aula Magna of a Catholic Institute
IT | EN | ES | DE | FR | PT
June 16 2015

The emergency turns into welcome. Outpouring of solidarity for the refugees in Italy. The actions of Sant'Egidio are multiplied

IT | EN | FR
May 25 2015
SAN SALVADOR, EL SALVADOR

The people of Sant'Egidio in the streets of San Salvador for the blessed Romero, the martyr of charity


Photogallery
IT | EN | ES | DE | FR | PT
May 24 2015

Beatification of Mons. Romero: Sant'Egidio at the celebration of the people of El Salvador around their shepherd


Hundreds of thousands of people at the liturgy in San Salvador. The relic is the shirt the bishop was wearing on the day of martyrdom. And a rainbow appears in the sky around the sun
IT | EN | ES | DE | FR | PT | UK
May 8 2015
SARAJEVO, BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA

Tuscan students in Sarajevo with Sant'Egidio to remember the war in the Balkans.


The journey 20 years after the signing of the Dayton Accords. Card. Puljic: "You are hope for the Europe of the future"
IT | EN | FR
April 19 2015
Press Release

Shipwreck of immigrants, Sant'Egidio: it is not possible to wait. If Europe is not up to the task, let the UN intervene


Triton does not work: it is necessary to stop the massacres of the sea immediately, to create a network for regular asylum applications and to multiply the diplomatic efforts to stop ongoing wars
IT | EN | ES | DE | FR | PT | PL | UK
all related news

NEWS HIGHLIGHTS
July 27 2015 | ABOMEY CALAVI, BENIN

The youth of Benin against the stigma and isolation of the elderly

IT | EN | ES | FR

ASSOCIATED PRESS
July 28 2015
Radio Vaticana
L'Ungheria: Paese diviso sulle politiche sull'immigrazione
July 25 2015
Avvenire
Comunità di Sant'Egidio. Sarà a Tirana la XXIX edizione di "Uomini e religioni"
July 25 2015
Corriere del Veneto
Partite a calcio e lezioni di italiano, l'altra faccia del Veneto che accoglie
July 24 2015
Il Gazzettino
Dibattito sui profughi: «Paure esagerate»
July 20 2015
La Provincia Pavese
Gli universitari di Sant'Egidio vanno a trovare i profughi
all press-related

BOOKS
Making Peace



New City
Religions and Violence



Claretian Communications Foundation, Inc.
more books

08/05/2015
Memory of the Saints and the Prophets

The Everyday Prayer


FOLLOW LIVE THE EVENT
Sarajevo 2012